Football’s decline has some high schools disbanding teams
Football’s decline has some high schools disbanding teams
Victory is never permanent
- PeteRasche
- Cornerstone
- Posts: 30922
- Joined: Wed Jul 20, 2005 11:52 am
- Location: Cincinnati, OH
Re: Football’s decline has some high schools disbanding team
I'm absolutely seeing this among fellow parents of kids 0 through 10 here in the Midwest. The article astutely points out that there is less decline in the south (where football is barely a notch below religion) and parts of the west (presumably California, where football is huge, though that has always surprised me since Californians are famous for overprotectiveness).
It will be really interesting to see what happens. Data needs to be shown - and fast - that the new helmet technology is working and prevents these long term effects. A coworker suggested, and I guess in a worst-case scenario I'd agree, that without changes and proof of safety, football will become like boxing: a sport only played by the poor who sacrifice the risk in lieu of having a "way out" of a bad situation otherwise. The educated and/or "better off" folks generally aren't taking the risk with their children's future health.
It will be really interesting to see what happens. Data needs to be shown - and fast - that the new helmet technology is working and prevents these long term effects. A coworker suggested, and I guess in a worst-case scenario I'd agree, that without changes and proof of safety, football will become like boxing: a sport only played by the poor who sacrifice the risk in lieu of having a "way out" of a bad situation otherwise. The educated and/or "better off" folks generally aren't taking the risk with their children's future health.
- TUPF
- Emerald Circle
- Posts: 21455
- Joined: Fri Jun 25, 2004 11:36 am
- Location: Maryland Eastern Shore & sometimes Philly
Re: Football’s decline has some high schools disbanding team
As a Bayshore Football Official doing games ranging from Annapolis to Ocean City, MD I can attest to what the article says. Part of it is the size of the schools but part of it is parents saying they don’t want to risk injuries. The sport better listen.
Fan since 1974 living in Phelps seeing the upper bowl of Tulane Stadium
Re: Football’s decline has some high schools disbanding team
If/When I have a son, I don't know if I'd let him play. It's not just the potential for head injury, which I don't think is as great in grade school and HS with proper technique, but the life long other issues. I have a two bad ankles, a bad knee, a bad shoulder, and disk issues. That said football taught me a lot about perseverance, team work, and responsibility so it would be a hard decision to make.
Using big words is not a personal attack
#cousins don't count
#cousins don't count
- TUPF
- Emerald Circle
- Posts: 21455
- Joined: Fri Jun 25, 2004 11:36 am
- Location: Maryland Eastern Shore & sometimes Philly
Re: Football’s decline has some high schools disbanding team
I wimped out from having to make that decision for my now 31 year old daughter, and in the 90s folks were not yet seeing what we now see. I’ll tell you, when I officiate Pop Warner games and see 120 lb. 12 year olds laying wood on 80 lb. 10 year olds, I cringe. The mismatches are much worse than what I see in JV or varsity games. BTW, there are one or two girls playing Pop Warner.windywave wrote:If/When I have a son, I don't know if I'd let him play. It's not just the potential for head injury, which I don't think is as great in grade school and HS with proper technique, but the life long other issues. I have a two bad ankles, a bad knee, a bad shoulder, and disk issues. That said football taught me a lot about perseverance, team work, and responsibility so it would be a hard decision to make.
Fan since 1974 living in Phelps seeing the upper bowl of Tulane Stadium
Re: Football’s decline has some high schools disbanding team
F=MA ... I played O and D line or TE most of my life so I used my hands a lot and when getting tackled the munchkin DBs went low so I had little head to head contact. It's the guys who take running starts to tackle and the folks getting tackled that I think have the most chance to have an issue.TUPF wrote:I wimped out from having to make that decision for my now 31 year old daughter, and in the 90s folks were not yet seeing what we now see. I’ll tell you, when I officiate Pop Warner games and see 120 lb. 12 year olds laying wood on 80 lb. 10 year olds, I cringe. The mismatches are much worse than what I see in JV or varsity games. BTW, there are one or two girls playing Pop Warner.windywave wrote:If/When I have a son, I don't know if I'd let him play. It's not just the potential for head injury, which I don't think is as great in grade school and HS with proper technique, but the life long other issues. I have a two bad ankles, a bad knee, a bad shoulder, and disk issues. That said football taught me a lot about perseverance, team work, and responsibility so it would be a hard decision to make.
Using big words is not a personal attack
#cousins don't count
#cousins don't count
- gerryb323
- Regent's Circle
- Posts: 9660
- Joined: Thu Jul 01, 2010 11:18 am
- Location: There's no place like home
Re: Football’s decline has some high schools disbanding team
More like E = mv2, but yeah ;)windywave wrote:F=MA ... I played O and D line or TE most of my life so I used my hands a lot and when getting tackled the munchkin DBs went low so I had little head to head contact. It's the guys who take running starts to tackle and the folks getting tackled that I think have the most chance to have an issue.TUPF wrote:I wimped out from having to make that decision for my now 31 year old daughter, and in the 90s folks were not yet seeing what we now see. I’ll tell you, when I officiate Pop Warner games and see 120 lb. 12 year olds laying wood on 80 lb. 10 year olds, I cringe. The mismatches are much worse than what I see in JV or varsity games. BTW, there are one or two girls playing Pop Warner.windywave wrote:If/When I have a son, I don't know if I'd let him play. It's not just the potential for head injury, which I don't think is as great in grade school and HS with proper technique, but the life long other issues. I have a two bad ankles, a bad knee, a bad shoulder, and disk issues. That said football taught me a lot about perseverance, team work, and responsibility so it would be a hard decision to make.
Wandering around somewhere in a matchup zone
Re: Football’s decline has some high schools disbanding team
And just like many things in the media today, it is so overblown and sensationalized that it leads to false conclusions - like 95% of NFL players have CTE. There was a good article which debunked many of the stats (when Concussion came out, can't find it now). Helps ad dollars when there's something negative to talk about.windywave wrote:If/When I have a son, I don't know if I'd let him play. It's not just the potential for head injury, which I don't think is as great in grade school and HS with proper technique, but the life long other issues. I have a two bad ankles, a bad knee, a bad shoulder, and disk issues. That said football taught me a lot about perseverance, team work, and responsibility so it would be a hard decision to make.
There are many things in life that are a risk. I feel my son playing football outweighs the risks. My opinion, I get it. But if we take the same approach to other interests and hobbies, we'd all be sitting in our homes reading or on the phones - period. What a great life that would be.
Bring home da Wave!
- Roller
- Cornerstone
- Posts: 36994
- Joined: Sat Jun 19, 2004 7:30 pm
- Location: 9½° due east of The Tulane University of Louisiana
Re: Football’s decline has some high schools disbanding team
+doncecco wrote:And just like many things in the media today, it is so overblown and sensationalized that it leads to false conclusions - like 95% of NFL players have CTE. There was a good article which debunked many of the stats (when Concussion came out, can't find it now). Helps ad dollars when there's something negative to talk about.windywave wrote:If/When I have a son, I don't know if I'd let him play. It's not just the potential for head injury, which I don't think is as great in grade school and HS with proper technique, but the life long other issues. I have a two bad ankles, a bad knee, a bad shoulder, and disk issues. That said football taught me a lot about perseverance, team work, and responsibility so it would be a hard decision to make.
There are many things in life that are a risk. I feel my son playing football outweighs the risks. My opinion, I get it. But if we take the same approach to other interests and hobbies, we'd all be sitting in our homes reading or on the phones - period. What a great life that would be.
Re: Football’s decline has some high schools disbanding team
Here in Kingsport there has been a student who has a second foam fitting over his regular helmet; I was told by the team physician (an orthopedics colleague) that the cost is an additional $500 on top of the $700 each helmet costs, is being used in him because of the number of concussions he has had. He has been told one more concussion and his football career is over. I happened to notice that the player had not dressed out this Past Friday, but had his left arm in a sling.
Personally if he were my son, that helmet would not be needed, because the only thing he would be playing would be trumpet or tuba in the band after that many concussions.
Personally if he were my son, that helmet would not be needed, because the only thing he would be playing would be trumpet or tuba in the band after that many concussions.
What if the Hokey Pokey really is what it's all about?
Re: Football’s decline has some high schools disbanding team
Did you just gloss over my post or not comprehend what I said? I said a bigger concern for me is the lifelong nagging injuries I have from football not CTE. Carry on.doncecco wrote:And just like many things in the media today, it is so overblown and sensationalized that it leads to false conclusions - like 95% of NFL players have CTE. There was a good article which debunked many of the stats (when Concussion came out, can't find it now). Helps ad dollars when there's something negative to talk about.windywave wrote:If/When I have a son, I don't know if I'd let him play. It's not just the potential for head injury, which I don't think is as great in grade school and HS with proper technique, but the life long other issues. I have a two bad ankles, a bad knee, a bad shoulder, and disk issues. That said football taught me a lot about perseverance, team work, and responsibility so it would be a hard decision to make.
There are many things in life that are a risk. I feel my son playing football outweighs the risks. My opinion, I get it. But if we take the same approach to other interests and hobbies, we'd all be sitting in our homes reading or on the phones - period. What a great life that would be.
Using big words is not a personal attack
#cousins don't count
#cousins don't count
Re: Football’s decline has some high schools disbanding team
I think going to foam helmets and shoulder pads would be the way to go. The hard plastic transfers the energy and encourages hitting with the head, because you feel like you're in armor.AO Sig wrote:Here in Kingsport there has been a student who has a second foam fitting over his regular helmet; I was told by the team physician (an orthopedics colleague) that the cost is an additional $500 on top of the $700 each helmet costs, is being used in him because of the number of concussions he has had. He has been told one more concussion and his football career is over. I happened to notice that the player had not dressed out this Past Friday, but had his left arm in a sling.
Personally if he were my son, that helmet would not be needed, because the only thing he would be playing would be trumpet or tuba in the band after that many concussions.
Using big words is not a personal attack
#cousins don't count
#cousins don't count
- TUPF
- Emerald Circle
- Posts: 21455
- Joined: Fri Jun 25, 2004 11:36 am
- Location: Maryland Eastern Shore & sometimes Philly
Re: Football’s decline has some high schools disbanding team
The two football injuries I had in high school, a broken ankle and internal bleeding from getting hit in the kidney, would could not have been prevented using anything available at the time. It’s a violent sport. I loved it and still do, but I don’t kid myself.windywave wrote:I think going to foam helmets and shoulder pads would be the way to go. The hard plastic transfers the energy and encourages hitting with the head, because you feel like you're in armor.AO Sig wrote:Here in Kingsport there has been a student who has a second foam fitting over his regular helmet; I was told by the team physician (an orthopedics colleague) that the cost is an additional $500 on top of the $700 each helmet costs, is being used in him because of the number of concussions he has had. He has been told one more concussion and his football career is over. I happened to notice that the player had not dressed out this Past Friday, but had his left arm in a sling.
Personally if he were my son, that helmet would not be needed, because the only thing he would be playing would be trumpet or tuba in the band after that many concussions.
Fan since 1974 living in Phelps seeing the upper bowl of Tulane Stadium
Re: Football’s decline has some high schools disbanding team
And you'd still get those injuries today.TUPF wrote:The two football injuries I had in high school, a broken ankle and internal bleeding from getting hit in the kidney, would could not have been prevented using anything available at the time. It’s a violent sport. I loved it and still do, but I don’t kid myself.windywave wrote:I think going to foam helmets and shoulder pads would be the way to go. The hard plastic transfers the energy and encourages hitting with the head, because you feel like you're in armor.AO Sig wrote:Here in Kingsport there has been a student who has a second foam fitting over his regular helmet; I was told by the team physician (an orthopedics colleague) that the cost is an additional $500 on top of the $700 each helmet costs, is being used in him because of the number of concussions he has had. He has been told one more concussion and his football career is over. I happened to notice that the player had not dressed out this Past Friday, but had his left arm in a sling.
Personally if he were my son, that helmet would not be needed, because the only thing he would be playing would be trumpet or tuba in the band after that many concussions.
Using big words is not a personal attack
#cousins don't count
#cousins don't count
-
- Coach Level
- Posts: 1984
- Joined: Fri Jun 25, 2004 12:50 pm
Re: Football’s decline has some high schools disbanding team
And the treatment and conditioning is much better today. What passed for our athletic training staff in high school was a part-time chemistry teacher with a roll of tape and a bag of ice.
Re: Football’s decline has some high schools disbanding team
Don't forget salt tablets and rubbing some dirt on it!LawGreenie wrote:And the treatment and conditioning is much better today. What passed for our athletic training staff in high school was a part-time chemistry teacher with a roll of tape and a bag of ice.
More seriously, we didn't think about this stuff nor did our parents way back when. Safety technology does need to improve, but all sports carry risk (the two youthful injuries that give me issues in middle age are from baseball and moshing, respectively (no, not at the same time....)). Soccer carries significant concussion risk, too, although it's not talked about as much.
I have a nine year old son. He is very active in Tae Kwon Do, and has been for years. He wears protective gear but there's a risk, of course. The benefits he gets from participation outweigh that danger, at least for us. I doubt I would let him play tackle football at his age, although if he decides he wants to once he gets a few years older I would probably let him, given the safety equipment and staff now available at the places he would likely be attending middle/high school. It's worth noting that the Catholic schools down here only do flag football through seventh grade (there are tackle teams in the various park/recreation districts, though). Just my two cents; it's one of those things each parent has to consider individually, and I don't think there's a clear cut answer.
- PeteRasche
- Cornerstone
- Posts: 30922
- Joined: Wed Jul 20, 2005 11:52 am
- Location: Cincinnati, OH
Re: Football’s decline has some high schools disbanding team
People are just bigger, stronger, and faster than even 30 or 40 years ago, too. We all know the stats about how today's DBs are the size of 1950s linemen... With more speed and weight comes more damage.
There was a national story on our local news this morning about how females apparently take significantly longer to heal from concussions than males. Focus of the story was on a girls' high school soccer goalie who had already sustained two concussions this season alone. Didn't say how (presumably diving, rather than shots being drilled off her head?)
There was a national story on our local news this morning about how females apparently take significantly longer to heal from concussions than males. Focus of the story was on a girls' high school soccer goalie who had already sustained two concussions this season alone. Didn't say how (presumably diving, rather than shots being drilled off her head?)
- TUPF
- Emerald Circle
- Posts: 21455
- Joined: Fri Jun 25, 2004 11:36 am
- Location: Maryland Eastern Shore & sometimes Philly
Re: Football’s decline has some high schools disbanding team
Boy ain’t that the truth. I officiated a JV game this afternoon and they were the size of HS teams in the 70s. I think the biggest difference now is the combination of size and speed. Years ago you were big but never fast, fast but never big. I almost got blindsided today by a linebacker and reacted just in time.PeteRasche wrote:People are just bigger, stronger, and faster than even 30 or 40 years ago, too. We all know the stats about how today's DBs are the size of 1950s linemen... With more speed and weight comes more damage.
Fan since 1974 living in Phelps seeing the upper bowl of Tulane Stadium
- Fan Since '54
- Regent's Circle
- Posts: 9409
- Joined: Thu Jun 17, 2004 8:28 am
- Location: Back home again...Oak Park sub division
Re: Football’s decline has some high schools disbanding team
The problem is that football glamorizes big soul crushing hits. You don't make SportsCenter highlights with a tackle around the waist.
FS'54
FS'54
"...a hellava Hullabaloo"